November 23, 2017

Second shark net trial disaster for marine life


23 November 2017

The start of a second North Coast Shark Net Trial marks the beginning of six months where dozens or even hundreds of harmless marine creatures are likely to be caught or killed, with no proven additional safety for swimmers and other beachgoers, say Greens MPs Tamara Smith and Justin Field.

The NSW Government is pushing ahead with the outdated technology despite results from last Summer's six-month trial in the same region showing:

  •            the shark nets caught and/or killed 244 marine creatures during the course of the trial, including rays and endangered turtles; and
  •          SMART drumlines deployed in the same area caught more target sharks, with far fewer sharks deaths and almost no by catch.

Since the trial, Senate Estimates testimony has shown a decrease in community support for the shark net trial.

The Greens call on the NSW Government to heed the evidence and abandon ineffective and outdated shark nets and instead support non-lethal deterrent measures.

Member for Ballina Tamara Smith said, "The shark net trial on the North Coast was a demonstrated failure and should not be repeated.

"There is no scientific evidence and decreasing community support for putting shark nets back in the water this Summer.

"We all want to ensure people are as safe as possible when enjoying the beach and ocean while minimising the toll on marine life. Shark nets don't help achieve that balance."

Greens MP and Marine Spokesperson Justin Field said the NSW Government was letting fear, News Limited and shock jocks drive shark management in the state.

"The NSW government's shark net trial and program is more about spin than an effective shark deterrent measure - which they are not - and gives the community a false sense of security," he said.

"The Greens have supported targeted trials of SMART drumlines for scientific purposes and the trials on the North Coast have been promising with important data on shark behaviours being collected and very low by-catch and mortality rates of caught sharks.

"North Coast locals are already shark aware and overwhelmingly reject the idea of shark nets and unnecessarily harming marine animals. Sadly the NSW Government is continuing to pursue a shark management strategy based on fear," he said.

Full copy of The Green non-lethal approach to shark management here:

Continue Reading

March 15, 2024

The Greens submission to the government's STRA consultation process

Short-term holiday lets are tearing apart the social fabric of the region. With one in four homes being short-term rentals in Byron Shire, it’s no wonder we have a housing crisis.

Read More

January 18, 2023

The regions being most impacted by short-term rentals (Rent News)

The oversupply of short-term rentals is often touted as one of the leading causes of the rental crunch, but new data reveals some areas suffer more than others.

Read More

January 18, 2023

Position on holiday letting (Byron Echo)

Given the broken promise by the NSW Liberal-Nationals government on allowing Council to regulate the short-term rental accommodation (STRA) sector in the Byron Shire, The Echo asked NSW Labor what they would do if elected in March.

Read More

Join other supporters in taking action

Sign up to receive newsletters and occasional emails about important issues in our community from Tamara Smith MP.

Join the campaign