August 03, 2018

Shark policy should be guided by science not polls

Media Release

3 August 2018

Say no to shark nets - bycatch from the Northern Coast shark net trialA turtle caught in a shark net

Greens Member for Ballina Tamara Smith said today the NSW Government should listen to the science on the ineffectiveness of shark nets, not make it a popularity contest.

"The Primary Industries Minister said he would be guided by science when it came to shark mitigation strategies but he has ignored the science repeatedly,” said Ms Smith.

“There was ample evidence to show that shark nets on the north coast were not going to provide protection for swimmers and surfers by catching target species compared to the SMART drum lines but the Minister chose to play politics and exploit a division within the community after a spate of shark fatalities and encounters."

"Marine scientists might have been able to forgive the first trial but when the science came back saying it was a failure in terms of catching target shark species the right thing to do would have been to cancel it then and there," said Ms Smith.

Instead there was a second trial which resulted in only 2 target sharks being caught by nets and 143 non-target species being caught, resulting in the deaths of dolphins, turtles and rays.

"As the local State member and someone who has been highly proactive in seeking out actual non-lethal shark mitigation strategies for surfers - surfers have a slightly higher risk of a shark encounter compared to swimmers - I am completely flabbergasted that a community survey has been the touchstone for the Nationals on this issue."

"You need scientifically proven effectiveness of shark deterrents when lives are at stake, not opinion polls.  Whether a method works or not is not a matter for polls - it either is, or it isn't, effective at protecting lives,” said Ms Smith.


Tell the government that shark nets don't work - just look at the results of two shark net trials - sign the Say No to Shark Nets petition

Continue Reading

March 15, 2024

The Greens submission to the government's STRA consultation process

Short-term holiday lets are tearing apart the social fabric of the region. With one in four homes being short-term rentals in Byron Shire, it’s no wonder we have a housing crisis.

Read More

January 18, 2023

The regions being most impacted by short-term rentals (Rent News)

The oversupply of short-term rentals is often touted as one of the leading causes of the rental crunch, but new data reveals some areas suffer more than others.

Read More

January 18, 2023

Position on holiday letting (Byron Echo)

Given the broken promise by the NSW Liberal-Nationals government on allowing Council to regulate the short-term rental accommodation (STRA) sector in the Byron Shire, The Echo asked NSW Labor what they would do if elected in March.

Read More

Join other supporters in taking action

Sign up to receive newsletters and occasional emails about important issues in our community from Tamara Smith MP.

Join the campaign